One of the most confusing parts of my motherhood journey? Pacifiers. I was making a baby gear list when someone randomly suggested adding one. Wait, do I even need this? I was exclusively breastfeeding and had no clue if a pacifier was a good idea. Cue the endless questions: Is it safe? Will it affect breastfeeding? What’s the best material? So, I did what any mom would—I researched like crazy. I read reviews, talked to fellow moms, and even consulted a pediatrician. After all that, I decided to give it a shot. And so began my great pacifier hunt! I compared brands, tested shapes, and now, I know way too much about pacifiers. But lucky for you, I’m here to make things easier. In this guide, I’ll share the best pacifier for breastfed baby, so you don’t have to go through the same exhausting search.
So, let’s get into the details.
Do Docs Recommend Pacifiers?
Credit: chiccousa.com
Hi moms, you are probably asking, Do doctors really recommend pacifiers? The brief response—yes, but with a few significant guidelines. Especially when nothing else works, pediatricians and specialists frequently advise that the best pacifier for breastfed baby can be a wonderful tool for enabling self-soothing. They can also help lower the SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) risk, comforting many parents.
But here’s the catch: although pacifiers for newborn breastfed babies have advantages, improper use could result in drawbacks. Doctors, therefore, advise starting a pacifier at the appropriate time and using it sensibly.
Here’s what pediatricians and doctors have to say about using the best baby pacifiers for your little one:
- Safe when used properly – A pacifier for a breastfed baby is fine as long as it’s clean, the right size, and used in moderation. Sometimes, excessive use could lead to dental problems like an open bite in young children.
- Reduces SIDS risk– Though doctors aren’t quite certain why, studies indicate that infants who use pacifiers for newborn breastfed babies at night have a decreased SIDS risk.
- Self -soothing Effect – Encourages baby self-soothing. During meltdowns, doctor appointments, and fussy evenings when nothing else appears to soothe your child, the best baby pacifiers can be a godsend.
- Not advised too soon – Introducing a pacifier before breastfeeding is well-known (often before 3-4 weeks) can result in nipple confusion, which would make it more difficult for babies to latch correctly.
- Should be eased off later— Using a pacifier for too long, beyond age 2–3, can cause dental problems like misplaced main teeth or alterations in the child’s tooth structure.
What’s So Good About Baby Pacifiers?
Credit: todaysparent.com
I used to believe a pacifier was only a tiny plastic item to stop babies from crying—until I gave my child one. But wow, was I wrong! When used properly, the best pacifiers for breastfed baby are tiny wonder workers. They help with sleep, stress, and even certain dental health issues, in addition to soothing a cranky baby.
Here’s why pacifiers for breastfed babies can be total lifesavers:
- 🎯 Soothes and calms –Babies have a natural sucking reflex, and the best pacifiers for breastfed baby help satisfy that without needing constant nursing. Perfect when you need a break!
- 💤 May reduce SIDS risk – Some studies show that introducing pacifiers for newborn breastfed babies during naps and bedtime can lower the risk of SIDS.
- 🍼 Eases discomfort – Pacifiers for breastfed babies can help with teething pain, gas discomfort, and even ear infections by helping babies regulate ear pressure.
- 🚗 Great for car rides – No more screaming during long drives! A pacifier for a breastfed baby can keep your little one calm while you focus on the road.
- 💡 Provides comfort without feeding – Sometimes babies just need to suck for comfort, not because they’re hungry. The best pacifiers for a breastfed baby can help without the need for constant nursing or bottle-feeding.
- 🦷 Better than thumb-sucking – Pacifiers and thumb-sucking are both ways babies self-soothe, but a pacifier is easier to phase out than sucking on primary teeth or thumbs.
- 🚫 Avoid dipping pacifiers – Some parents try dipping pacifiers for breastfed babies in honey or juice to encourage use, but this can lead to tooth decay and dental issues.
When to Introduce Pacifiers to Babies?
Credit: pnmag.com
When it comes to starting a pacifier, timing is everything. Introduce them too soon, and you can disrupt nursing. Wait too long, and the baby might totally disregard them. So, when is the ideal moment?
Most doctors, including the Academy of Pediatric Dentistry, recommend waiting until breastfeeding is well-established, usually around 3 to 4 weeks. Nipple confusion is not an issue; hence, if your infant is bottle-fed, you may typically start using a pacifier sooner.
Note: The average age to start pacifiers for breastfed babies is generally 3-4 weeks of age.
Key Tips for Introducing a Pacifier
- ⏳ Wait until breastfeeding is established – If you’re nursing, hold off on introducing a pacifier until your baby is latching and feeding well (usually around 3-4 weeks).
- 🍼 Bottle-fed babies can start earlier – Since bottle-fed babies don’t need to develop the same kind of latch, they can often start using baby pacifiers sooner.
- 🌙 Use at sleep time – Many experts suggest offering a pacifier for a breastfed baby at naps and bedtime, as it can help with falling asleep and may reduce the risk of SIDS.
- 🚫 Don’t force it – Not all babies take to pacifiers for breastfed babies, and that’s okay! If your baby doesn’t seem interested, don’t stress—it’s not a must-have for every child.
- 🦷 Wean your child before dental issues arise – To prevent problems like open bite and misaligned front teeth, most pediatricians and pediatric dentists recommend gradually phasing out pacifiers around age 2, and definitely by age 3.
- 🦷 Watch for pacifier teeth toddler problems – Prolonged pacifier use can sometimes affect a baby’s tooth alignment. If you notice changes, consult a pediatric dentist for advice on possible mouth appliances to correct early signs of an issue.
- 🚫 Break the habit gently – If your toddler is attached to their best baby pacifiers, try a slow weaning approach instead of taking them away suddenly.
Let’s now discuss different options for the best pacifier for breastfed babies.
Best Simple Design
Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier
Credit: amazon.com
Binky Benefits
- Breast-like Design
- BPS Free, BPA Free
- Pattern: Solid
- Color: Pastel/Blue/Black
Age Range
0-6 months
Shape
Breast-like Nipple
Nibble Know-How
- Wait Until Breastfeeding Is Established: Avoid nipple confusion by introducing it later.
- Keep It Clean: Sterilize regularly for oral health and to prevent ear infections.
- Check for Damage: Worn-out pacifiers can harm a baby’s teeth.
- Use a Clip: Keeps the pacifier clean and within reach.
The first pacifier for the breastfed baby I tried on my motherhood journey was the Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier. As a mom who is exclusively breastfeeding, I was worried about nipple confusion, but this one seemed promising! Anything claiming to mimic the real thing is worth a shot when you’re trying to find the best pacifier for breastfed baby.
Honestly, I was anxious when I was handed this pacifier to my kid. Would it confuse the nipple? Would she even take it? Surprisingly, she grabbed it right away! While nevertheless encouraging her natural sucking response, the breast-like pacifier provided her the comfort she sought.
For car trips, nap time, and calming those rare meltdowns, it quickly became our best baby pacifier. I also appreciated that it appeared to have no impact on breastfeeding or problems with her pacifier teeth toddler development. It also let her sleep more easily, which was a win for both of us!
Finding the best pacifier for a breastfed baby isn’t easy, but the Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier worked wonders for us.
Best Lightweight Pacifier
Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers
Credit: babykingdom.com
Binky Benefits
- Material: Silicone
- BPA Free & dishwasher safe
- Pattern: Solid
- Color: Grey
Age Range
0-3 months
Shape
Orthodontic Shape
Nibble Know-How
- Introduce this pacifier after breastfeeding is well established.
- Keep it clean by sterilizing regularly (dishwasher safe = win!)
- Use a pacifier clip to avoid it falling on the floor.
- If your baby rejects it at first, try again when they’re sleepy!
The next pacifier I tried was the Nanobebe Baby Pacifier, and let me tell you—it caught my attention instantly! The shape looked so unique, and I was curious to see if my breastfed baby would love it. Plus, it claimed to be extra soft and lightweight, which sounded perfect for a newborn.
I first heard about the Nanobebe Baby Pacifier from a mom friend who swore it was perfect for breastfed babies. Desperate for something to help my little one fall asleep without causing nipple confusion, I gave it a shot. To my surprise, he latched onto it instantly! The curved design fit his tiny face perfectly, and since it was super lightweight, it actually stayed put. Nighttime? A lifesaver. He started self-soothing better, and naps became so much easier. Safe to say, this pacifier quickly became our best pacifier for breastfed baby in the house.
So, in a nutshell, it’s simple, easy to clean, and perfect for keeping your newborn happy. Definitely a mom win.
Before we wrap up, why not look at some of the reviews by trusted parents?
It’s simple, easy to clean, and perfect for keeping your newborn happy. Definitely a mom win!
Here’s another one:
The only chupies my daughter wanted!! Amazing durability, even when my girl got her teeth and was chewing it, trying to rip it apart, it never tore, and no holes! Easy to clean, I love how easy it was to attach to a chupie clip. The colors are so cute, so worth the money! Lightweight and definitely a favorite!
Alright, I think that’s pretty much it about this top pacifier for a breastfed baby. Let’s move on to the next one.
Best for Sensitive Skin
MAM Original Newborn Baby Pacifier
Credit: macrobaby.com
Binky Benefits
- Self-sterilizing case
- Soft silicone nipple
- Pattern: Animal Print
- Color: Peppermint / Cotton
Age Range
0-3 months
Shape
Symmetrical
Nibble Know-How
- Always use the sterilizing case for easy cleaning.
- If your baby refuses at first, try offering it when they’re drowsy.b
- Rotate between a couple of pacifiers to prevent dependency on just one.
I first came across the MAM Original Start Pacifier when I was searching for something extra gentle on my baby’s skin. A mom in my parenting group raved about how soft and breathable it was. So, of course, I had to try it.
This pacifier was a game-changer. My little one took to it immediately, and I loved that the lightweight shield didn’t leave marks on his delicate cheeks. The best pacifiers for breastfed baby should be comfortable and safe, and this one checked all the boxes. The silicone nipple felt super soft, and I noticed he was much calmer when using it. Plus, the self-sterilizing case? A total win! Just a quick microwave zap, and it’s good to go—so convenient for busy moms like me.
So, Moms, listen up, if you’re looking for a gentle, easy-to-clean pacifier that’s newborn-friendly, this one’s a must-try.
Bonus: No red marks on chubby cheeks!
If you thought that one was good, just wait—our next pick is another standout that’s worth checking out.
Best Hospital-Trusted Choice
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier
Credit: littlecanadian.ca
Binky Benefits
- Material: Silicone
- Bpa-free, Latex-free
- Fingerheld solution
- Color: Green
Age Range
0-3 months
Shape
One-piece, Round
Nibble Know-How
- Run it under warm water before first use to soften it up.
- Pop it in the dishwasher for quick cleaning.
- If the baby won’t take it at first, try rubbing a little breast milk on it.
My pediatrician mentioned the Philips Avent Soothie in passing, saying it’s the same pacifier used in hospitals. That instantly caught my attention! If doctors trust it for newborns, I figured it had to be worth a try.
Here’s our next must-have! The Philips Avent Soothie is simple, yet genius. It’s designed to be super safe and easy to clean—no tiny parts or hidden spaces where germs can sneak in. The soft silicone feels just like mom, making it a lifesaver for soothing fussy babies. It’s truly a great pacifier for breastfed baby since it mimics the natural feel, helping to avoid nipple confusion. I also loved that it’s durable—my little one could chomp on it all day, and it never lost its shape.
Bonus? You can even attach it to a pacifier clip so it doesn’t vanish into the black hole of baby gear!
Why not look at a review by a regular parent who has used this pacifier?
Even though my new baby is not a fan of avent these really are great pacifiers. They are easy to clean and steam and adaptable to any pacifier holder.
If you want a trusted, hospital-grade pacifier that’s durable and safe, this is it. It’s a no-fuss, no-drama solution for keeping babies happy—just how we moms like it.
Okay, that one definitely impressed me, but wait until you see this next pick—it has its own unique charm.
Best Natural Rubber Pacifier
Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifiers
Credit: itzyritzy.com
Binky Benefits
- 100% natural rubber
- Bpa-free
- Vented shield
- Color: Coconut/Toast
Age Range
0-6 months
Shape
Round nipple
Nibble Know-How
- Always sterilize before first use—a quick boil for 5 minutes should do.
- Replace every 4-6 weeks since natural rubber wears out faster than silicone.
- Store in a cool, dry place to maintain its softness.
Another amazing product on our list is the Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifier. Being a mom, I must tell you that this one is made from natural materials—something safe, soft, and free from unnecessary chemicals. The cute, modern design was a bonus!
This Itzy Ritzy pacifier is all about natural comfort. Made from 100% natural rubber, it’s soft, flexible, and mimics the feel of mom, making it a great option for breastfed babies. The round nipple shape is ideal for little ones who prefer a more traditional feel. Plus, the vented shield helps reduce irritation around your baby’s mouth, because no one likes those pesky red marks! And can we talk about the adorable colors? Seriously, it’s the kind of pacifier you wouldn’t mind seeing in all your baby photos.
It’s safe, soft, and easy on little cheeks. Plus, it’s just plain cute—because let’s be real, baby gear should look good too.
That was a solid choice, right? Now, let’s check out another one that brings something special to the table.
Best Lightweight Silicone Pacifier
Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci Pacifier
Credit: drbrownsbaby.com
Binky Benefits
- One-piece design
- Bpa-free
- Butterfly-shaped shield leaves
- Color: Gray, Green, Ecru
Age Range
0-6 months
Shape
Orthodontic
Nibble Know-How
- Always sterilize before first use—a quick boil for 5 minutes should do.
- Replace every 4-6 weeks since natural rubber wears out faster than silicone.
- Store in a cool, dry place to maintain its softness.
And here we are—the last pick on our list, no doubt one of the best pacifier for breastfed baby! The Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci is a simple, soft, and lightweight pacifier designed with comfort in mind. If you’re looking for a pacifier that mimics the shape of a bottle nipple, this one is a great pick, especially for babies who already love Dr. Brown’s bottles.
Last but certainly not least, we have the Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci. I have to say, this one just makes sense—especially if your baby already uses Dr. Brown’s bottles. The nipple shape is almost identical, making it a seamless transition for babies who are picky about pacifiers.
The super lightweight design is another win—it stays in the baby’s mouth more easily, so you’re not constantly popping it back in. And let’s talk about the butterfly shield—it gives plenty of space around baby’s nose, so they can breathe easily while sucking away. Plus, it’s all one piece, so cleaning is a total breeze.
The Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci is light, soft, and easy to love. If your little one already uses Dr. Brown’s bottles, this is a no-brainer.
And there you have it—some of the best pacifiers out there. No matter which one you choose, the most important thing is finding what works best for your little one (and gives you a little peace too!)
Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies
Picking the right pacifier for a breastfed baby can feel like a bit of a guessing game. You want something that won’t mess with breastfeeding or cause nipple confusion, but still gives your little one the comfort they need. The trick? I’ve got your back.
Here’s what to look for:
- Breast-like Shape – A rounded or flattened nipple helps prevent nipple confusion and makes the transition between breastfeeding and pacifiers easier.
- Soft, Squishy Material – Silicone or natural rubber works best for a gentle, skin-like feel, which supports your baby’s sucking reflex.
- One-Piece Design – No extra parts = no sneaky spots for germs to hide (because who has time for that?) and it’s safer for your newborn.
- Orthodontic-Friendly – Choosing the best pacifier for a breastfed baby helps promote good oral health and prevents future dental issues like an open bite.
- Lightweight & Easy to Hold – A lightweight design makes it easier for your baby to keep in their mouth while falling asleep without constantly needing you to pop it back in.
Finding the best baby pacifiers might take a little trial and error, but once you do, it’s a total game-changer.
Before we wrap up, why not have a look at a guide on types of pacifiers and how to choose one.
End Note
In a nutshell, this article focuses on the best pacifier for a breastfed baby. Check out these options and choose a pacifier now.
Which Design You Liked The Most?
Leave a comment